GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH 鈥衡�� 2011, Vol. 30 鈥衡�� Issue (1): 61-70.DOI: 10.11821/yj2011010006

鈥� Earth Surface Processes 鈥� Previous Articles     Next Articles

Space of fragmentation: A study of the linkages between gated communities and their neighborhoods in Guangzhou, China

FENG Dan1, Werner Breitung1, ZHU Hong1,2   

  1. 1. School of Geography and Planning, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou 510275, China;
    2. School of Geography, South China Normal University, Guangzhou 510631, China
  • Received:2010-04-13 Revised:2010-08-28 Online:2011-01-20 Published:2011-01-20

浣忓畢閮婂尯鍖栬儗鏅笅闂ㄧ绀惧尯涓庡懆杈归偦閲屽叧绯�——浠ュ箍宸炰附姹熻姳鍥负渚�

灏佷腹1, Werner Breitung1, 鏈辩珣1,2   

  1. 1. 涓北澶у鍦扮悊绉戝涓庤鍒掑闄�,骞垮窞 510275;
    2. 鍗庡崡甯堣寖澶у鍦扮悊绉戝瀛﹂櫌,骞垮窞 510631
  • 閫氳浣滆��: 鏈辩珣,鐢�,鏁欐巿,鍗氬+鐢熷甯�,涓昏浠庝簨鏂囧寲鍦扮悊鍜屽巻鍙插湴鐞嗙爺绌躲�侲-mail: zhuh@ scnu.edu.cn.
  • 浣滆�呯畝浠�:灏佷腹(1982-), 濂�, 姹熻嫃娉板窞浜�,鍗氬+鐮旂┒鐢�,涓昏浠庝簨鏂囧寲鍦扮悊鍜屽煄甯傚彂灞曠爺绌躲�� E-mail: fengdan111@qq.com
  • 鍩洪噾璧勫姪:

    鍥藉鑷劧绉戝鍩洪噾椤圭洰 (40771067);German Research Council(BR 3546/1-2)

Abstract: The rise of gated communities has become a global phenomenon with the appearance both in developed countries such as North American and European countries and in Asia, Latin America, South America, and South Africa. Accordingly, discussion about this type of private communities has been largely inspired by observations in various cities worldwide. Most of the insights towards gated communities are negative, regarding them as urban enclaves and relating this spatial fragmentation to residential segregation and social exclusion. However, due to different social and cultural backgrounds, the implications and consequences of gated communities in different places may not be exhibited in the same way. Local experience seems to be of great significance to the debate on the social effects of gated communities. The emergence of gated communities in China is a relatively nascent urban phenomenon even though enclosed housing compounds have cultural roots in China's history. Against the context of urban sprawl, gated communities invade into rural areas of China, co-standing to mix with traditional villages. Through a case study of a neighborhood named Lijiang Garden in the suburban Panyu District in Guangzhou, this paper explores the relationship between residents of gated communities and outsiders, addressing the material connections of gated community in suburban area of China to the outside world, conceptions and attitudes of residents living in both sides towards each other, exploring social contacts between them, in order to examine the impacts of gated communities on local areas. The empirical study revealed that the physical existence of wall does not mean gated community which can be seen as enclave in China since the functional connections and social contacts can be observed between gated community and its poorer neighborhood. Furthermore, the perceptions and attitudes towards each other are not negative, especially the outsiders of gated communities in China have not, psychologically, been segregated by the new walls, so that little negative impacts of gated communities are perceived in the suburban districts of urban China. Thought sharing certain similarities, the findings in China challenge the prevalent view of gated communities worldwide. It is demonstrated that gated communities should be investigated by considering specific local economic, cultural and political contexts.

Key words: gated communities, segregation, Guangzhou, China

鎽樿锛� 浣滀负"鐮寸鍩庡競"鐨勫吀鍨嬭〃寰�,瑗挎柟瀛﹁�呭闂ㄧ绀惧尯鎸佽礋闈㈡�佸害,鐒惰�岄棬绂佺ぞ鍖哄湪涓嶅悓鍖哄煙鐨勫嚭鐜板彈鍒朵簬褰撳湴鐨勭ぞ浼氭枃鍖栬绱�,骞跺彲鑳藉褰撳湴浜х敓涓嶅悓鐨勫奖鍝嶃�傛湰鏂囪瘯鍥炬帰璁ㄥ湪涓浗鐗规畩鐨勭ぞ浼氭枃鍖栬儗鏅笅,闂ㄧ绀惧尯涓庡懆杈圭ぞ浼氱粡娴庡湴浣嶈緝浣庨偦閲岀殑鑱旂郴鍜岀ぞ浼氬叧绯�,骞堕�氳繃鍒嗘瀽闂ㄧ绀惧尯灞呮皯鐨勬椿鍔ㄨ寖鍥村拰鍥村鍐呭灞呮皯褰兼闂寸殑鎬佸害鍜岀ぞ浼氫氦寰�鏉ユ帰璁ㄩ棬绂佺ぞ鍖虹殑褰卞搷銆備互骞垮窞鐣鍗楁郸宀涗附姹熻姳鍥负妗堜緥鍦�,缁撳悎闂嵎璋冩煡銆佹繁搴﹁璋堝拰鍙備笌寮忚瀵熺瓑鐮旂┒鏂规硶,鐮旂┒鍙戠幇:涓庡崡闈炪�侀樋鏍瑰环绛夊浗瀹朵笉鍚岀殑鏄�,鎴戝浗闂ㄧ绀惧尯涓庡懆杈归偦閲屽瓨鍦ㄥ姛鑳芥�т簰鍔�,骞舵湭缁欏懆杈归偦閲岄�犳垚琚殧绂诲拰琚瑙嗙殑蹇冪悊,鍦扮悊绌洪棿涓婄殑涓磋繎鎬у弽鑰屼负涓嶅悓闃跺眰鍜屼笉鍚岀敓娲昏儗鏅殑灞呮皯涔嬮棿鐨勭浉浜掍簡瑙c�佽瀺鍚堝拰娌熼�氭彁渚涗簡鏈轰細鍜屽彲鑳姐��

鍏抽敭璇�: 闂ㄧ绀惧尯, 閮婂尯鍖�, 绀句細闅旂, 骞垮窞